Quick Read
- Alan Tudyk revealed his role in ‘I, Robot’ tested higher than Will Smith’s, leading to his exclusion from the film’s publicity campaigns.
- Tudyk portrayed Sonny, a robot pivotal to the film’s plot, using motion capture and voice acting.
- ‘I, Robot’ was a commercial success, earning over $353 million globally and receiving an Oscar nomination for Best Visual Effects.
- Tudyk’s performance in ‘I, Robot’ is considered a milestone in performance capture technology.
- Since then, Tudyk has built a diverse career, including roles in ‘Resident Alien,’ ‘Rogue One,’ and various animated films.
Alan Tudyk, a versatile actor renowned for his roles in both live-action and animated projects, recently shared a surprising revelation about his experience working on the 2004 sci-fi blockbuster, I, Robot. Speaking on the podcast Toon’d In with Jim Cummings, Tudyk disclosed that his portrayal of Sonny, the film’s central robot character, outshone Will Smith’s lead role in test screenings, a development that ultimately led to his removal from the film’s publicity efforts.
The Role of Sonny and Tudyk’s Groundbreaking Performance
In I, Robot, directed by Alex Proyas, Alan Tudyk played Sonny, a highly advanced robot at the heart of a murder mystery. The film, set in 2035 Chicago, follows Detective Del Spooner (played by Will Smith) as he investigates the suspicious death of a robotics company’s founder. Tudyk’s Sonny is pivotal to the story, offering a layered performance that combined motion capture and voice acting—a relatively novel technique at the time.
Tudyk reflected on the challenges of bringing Sonny to life. “I put a lot into it,” he said, emphasizing the physical and emotional demands of the role. The actor had to embody robotic movements while delivering a voice performance that conveyed Sonny’s nuanced personality. According to USA Today, Tudyk’s dedication to the role has been referenced in discussions about the evolution of artificial intelligence and performance capture technology.
Overshadowed by Test Audience Success
Despite his groundbreaking performance, Tudyk’s character’s popularity with test audiences became a double-edged sword. He revealed that test screenings scored Sonny higher than Smith’s character, Del Spooner. “I got word back, ‘Alan, you’re testing higher than Will Smith,’” Tudyk said. This revelation, shared on the podcast and reported by Gizmodo, shocked Tudyk. Shortly after, he found himself excluded from the film’s promotional campaigns. “I was gone. There was no publicity, and my name was not mentioned,” he lamented.
The decision to remove Tudyk from the press tour appears to have been a strategic move by the studio, 20th Century Fox, to avoid overshadowing the film’s marquee star. While Will Smith has not publicly commented on Tudyk’s claims, the situation highlights the complexities of marketing big-budget films where star power often takes precedence.
The Legacy of I, Robot
Despite the behind-the-scenes drama, I, Robot was a commercial success, grossing over $353 million globally. The film was also nominated for an Academy Award for Best Visual Effects, though it ultimately lost to Spider-Man 2. Tudyk’s work as Sonny is often celebrated as a milestone in performance capture, a technique that has since become a staple in Hollywood blockbusters.
Reflecting on the film’s legacy, Tudyk noted that I, Robot remains relevant in discussions about artificial intelligence and robotics. “At the time, I was very upset,” Tudyk admitted, but he acknowledged that the role helped pave the way for future projects. His later work as K-2SO in Rogue One: A Star Wars Story and its prequel series, Andor, further cemented his reputation as a pioneer in performance capture.
Alan Tudyk’s Career Beyond I, Robot
Since I, Robot, Tudyk has built a diverse career spanning live-action and voice acting. His roles in animated films such as Moana, Zootopia, and Encanto have showcased his versatility, while live-action performances in projects like Resident Alien have demonstrated his range as an actor.
According to Complex, Tudyk expressed mixed feelings about his contributions to projects that rely heavily on technology and collaboration. “It feels like cheating,” he said of being considered for awards in voice or motion-capture roles. Nevertheless, his work continues to be celebrated by fans and critics alike.
I, Robot remains a significant chapter in Tudyk’s career, both for the challenges it presented and the opportunities it created. While the decision to sideline him from the film’s publicity may have been a disappointment, it has not diminished his contributions to the industry or the enduring impact of his performance as Sonny.
*Alan Tudyk’s story is a testament to the complexities of Hollywood, where talent and politics often intersect in unexpected ways.*

