Quick Read
- Universal Pictures debuts its live-action ‘How to Train Your Dragon’ remake in 2025.
- Mason Thames stars as Hiccup, delivering a heartfelt performance despite some miscasting concerns.
- The film stays true to the 2010 animated classic, sparking debates about the necessity of remakes.
In 2025, Universal Pictures took a bold leap by remaking the cherished 2010 animated classic, How to Train Your Dragon, into a live-action feature. Directed once again by Dean DeBlois, the remake has sparked both praise and debate. While the film successfully captures the heart of the original story, its adherence to the animated version raises questions about the purpose and value of such remakes.
Why Remake a Beloved Classic?
For fans of the original, How to Train Your Dragon holds a special place in cinematic history. Its touching narrative, stunning animation, and memorable characters resonated deeply with audiences of all ages. Universal’s decision to remake it in live-action form seems to stem from a broader trend in Hollywood, where remakes of beloved classics aim to attract both nostalgic fans and new generations.
However, as noted by critics, the live-action adaptation closely mirrors the animated original, with only minor tweaks to the storyline and dialogue. This fidelity has led some to question its artistic necessity. As Screencrush aptly pointed out, the remake feels like “cinematic déjà vu,” offering little innovation to distinguish itself from its predecessor.
Mason Thames as Hiccup: A Star in the Making
At the heart of the live-action remake is Mason Thames, who takes on the iconic role of Hiccup, a young Viking who befriends a dragon named Toothless. Thames delivers a compelling performance, capturing Hiccup’s courage and emotional depth. Yet, some critics have highlighted challenges in his casting. Unlike the lanky and awkward animated Hiccup, Thames appears more polished and mature, which slightly undercuts the character’s outsider status.
Despite this, Thames’ chemistry with Toothless—a CGI-rendered dragon who retains his animated design—remains a highlight of the film. Their bond is as heartwarming as ever, proving that the core emotional beats of the story still resonate.
Visuals and Performances: A Mixed Bag
Visually, the live-action How to Train Your Dragon is a spectacle. The dragons, with the exception of Toothless, receive impressive live-action updates, blending seamlessly into the film’s muted, realistic aesthetic. Berk, the Viking village, is brought to life with intricate detail, immersing viewers in its rugged landscapes and bustling community.
Gerard Butler reprises his role as Stoick the Vast, delivering a performance that feels like a direct extension of the animated character. Nico Parker’s portrayal of Astrid also stands out, adding depth and emotional weight to the story. Together, these performances anchor the film, even as it struggles with pacing issues in its first half.
The Broader Implications of Remakes
The live-action remake of How to Train Your Dragon is part of a larger Hollywood trend of revisiting animated classics. While these films often succeed commercially, they spark debates about the originality and creativity in contemporary cinema. As NPR noted, remakes aim to bridge the gap between older fans and younger audiences, but they risk alienating both by failing to offer fresh perspectives.
From an economic standpoint, such remakes are lucrative. They capitalize on established franchises, merchandise sales, and theme park tie-ins. Universal’s investment in a How to Train Your Dragon theme park land underscores the financial incentives driving this trend.
The Future of ‘How to Train Your Dragon’
With its heartfelt moments and stunning visuals, the live-action How to Train Your Dragon is likely to find its audience among families and fans of the original. However, its lack of originality may limit its long-term cultural impact. As Hollywood continues to explore the potential of remakes, striking a balance between nostalgia and innovation will be key to their success.
The live-action adaptation of How to Train Your Dragon serves as both a tribute to the original and a reminder of the challenges inherent in reimagining beloved stories. While it may not surpass its predecessor, it offers a heartfelt cinematic experience that will resonate with audiences young and old.