- Former NFL GM Ran Carthon shares pro comparisons for 2025 NFL Draft prospects.
- Quarterback Jalen Milroe compared to Malik Willis and Taysom Hill for his athleticism.
- Running back TreVeyon Henderson likened to Chase Brown for his explosiveness.
- Wide receiver Matthew Golden compared to Jordan Addison for his downfield playmaking.
- Defensive back Malachi Moore draws comparisons to Pro Bowler Micah Hyde.
2025 NFL Draft: Top Prospect Comparisons by Former GM
As the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, analysts and former league executives are busy evaluating the next wave of talent set to enter the league. One of the most insightful exercises in this process is drawing comparisons between draft prospects and current or former NFL players. These comparisons help teams and fans alike understand a player’s potential fit and impact at the professional level.
On a recent episode of the “With the First Pick” podcast, former Tennessee Titans general manager Ran Carthon joined host Ryan Wilson to share his favorite comparisons for the 2025 draft class. From quarterbacks to defensive backs, Carthon provided detailed insights into how these young players measure up to established NFL stars. Here’s a breakdown of some of the most compelling comparisons by position.
Quarterbacks: Athleticism and Pocket Passing Potential
Jalen Milroe, a quarterback with elite athleticism, drew comparisons to both Malik Willis and Taysom Hill. Carthon noted that Milroe shares Willis’s ability to squeeze the ball into tight windows but also struggles with processing plays quickly, a common issue for young quarterbacks. On the other hand, Milroe’s explosiveness with the ball in his hands reminded Carthon of Taysom Hill, a dynamic player often used in creative packages.
“In today’s game, I’m pretty sure you’re not going to have a guy with this type of ability just sitting on the sideline,” Carthon said, emphasizing Milroe’s potential to contribute even if he doesn’t start immediately.
Another quarterback, Kyle McCord, sparked debate between Carthon and Wilson. While Wilson compared McCord to Kirk Cousins for his growth and consistency, Carthon argued that McCord more closely resembles Jeff Driskel, citing differences in natural passing ability and ball release speed.
Running Backs: Explosiveness and Versatility
TreVeyon Henderson, one of the top running back prospects, was likened to Chase Brown for his ability to excel in zone-running schemes. Carthon highlighted Henderson’s decisiveness and explosiveness, traits that make him a likely early-round pick.
Omarion Hampton, another standout, drew comparisons to Joe Mixon. Both players are known for their physicality and ability to excel in pass protection. “Two guys who are a load to bring down,” Carthon said, emphasizing Hampton’s potential as a first-round pick.
Jaydon Blue’s agility and ability to make defenders miss earned him comparisons to Jahmyr Gibbs and James Cook. Carthon sees Blue thriving in a third-down role, where his speed and pass-catching ability could make him a significant offensive weapon.
Brashard Smith, transitioning from wide receiver to running back, was described as “electric” by Wilson and a “big, big fan” by Carthon. With time to learn the nuances of the position, Smith could become a versatile player who contributes as both a running back and a kick returner.
Wide Receivers: Playmaking and Complementary Roles
Matthew Golden, a wide receiver with size and downfield ability, was compared to Jordan Addison by Wilson. Carthon, however, sees Golden as a first-round pick who would thrive as a complementary piece to an established No. 1 receiver.
Isaac TeSlaa, another intriguing prospect, drew comparisons to Cooper Kupp and Jauan Jennings. While Wilson acknowledged that TeSlaa might not reach Kupp’s level, his size and ability to serve as a reliable target in the middle of the field make him a valuable asset.
Defensive Backs: Instincts and Versatility
Malachi Moore, praised for his intelligence and instincts, was compared to former Pro Bowler Micah Hyde. Carthon highlighted their similar measurables and above-average athleticism, making Moore a promising addition to any secondary.
Jahdae Barron, another defensive back, earned comparisons to Javon Bullard and Brian Branch. Wilson described Barron as a “locker room guy” with a deep understanding of the game, while Carthon noted his versatility as a “true matchup guy” who can be moved around the field.
Why Comparisons Matter
Player comparisons are more than just an exercise in imagination; they provide valuable context for evaluating a prospect’s potential. By likening a young player to an established NFL star, scouts and analysts can better communicate a prospect’s strengths, weaknesses, and likely role at the next level.
As the 2025 NFL Draft draws closer, these comparisons will continue to shape discussions around the top prospects. Whether it’s Jalen Milroe’s dynamic athleticism or Malachi Moore’s instincts, these young players have the potential to make a significant impact in the NFL.