Online Fan Backlash Draws Criticism From Former NBA Players
Former NBA player Etan Thomas has criticized the online backlash from portions of Caitlin Clark’s fanbase directed at her Indiana Fever teammates, most notably guard Kelsey Mitchell. In comments highlighted on Sports.Yahoo, Thomas argued on his YouTube podcast with sportswriter David Zirin that segments of the fanbase are engaging in a “continued weaponization of Caitlin Clark that treats every other talented woman on the roster like an inconvenience.”
The public discussion underscores growing tensions within WNBA supporter circles as the franchise navigates a complex offseason. Mitchell enters free agency following nine seasons with the Fever, a period during which she became an offensive cornerstone and established a historic backcourt partnership with Clark.
Player Accounts Highlight Roster Tensions
Thomas’s remarks reflect statements previously made by current and former Indiana Fever players regarding online scrutiny. In a 2024 exit interview, Aliyah Boston discussed experiencing harsh online commentary during difficult stretches of play. Mitchell similarly addressed the unique pressures of playing alongside high-profile teammates, noting that the roster frequently absorbs external criticism.
The friction extended into front-office commentary when former general manager Amber Cox defended the fanbase and characterized criticisms as baseless. That assessment was swiftly disputed by former Fever player Brianna Turner, who called the statement unequivocally false on Sports.Yahoo. Zirin added on his podcast that players like Mitchell and Boston face persistent online pushback simply for taking shot attempts or allegedly diminishing the central focus on Clark.
Offensive Stakes and Free Agency Uncertainty
As Mitchell weighs her options in free agency, her potential departure presents a significant challenge for the Indiana franchise. During the recent season, Mitchell delivered the most productive campaign of her career, averaging a career-high 24.7 points, 2.8 assists, and 1.0 steals per game while shooting 50.9% from the field and 45.0% from beyond the arc.
The record-setting offensive chemistry between Clark and Mitchell powered the Fever to become the league’s top-scoring offense. However, after suffering consecutive first-round playoff exits over three seasons with Clark, the front office faces mounting pressure to balance high-level offensive production with necessary defensive upgrades.

