The much-anticipated finale of Bachelor in Paradise season 10 aired on September 2, 2025, delivering a mix of emotional highs, unexpected twists, and memorable moments. This season introduced a unique “Love or Money” twist, adding stakes to the show’s traditional formula. With a $500,000 prize pool on the line, contestants faced a new level of pressure to prove their intentions and connections.
High-Stakes Drama and the “Love or Money” Test
In a groundbreaking twist, the finale challenged the final two couples—Jess Edwards & Spencer Conley and Alexe Godwin & Andrew Spencer—with a choice: love or money. Host Jesse Palmer explained the rules, emphasizing that while love was the ultimate goal, contestants could walk away with varying amounts of prize money. Both couples chose love, leading to a suspenseful envelope draw. Jess and Spencer selected the highest amount, $190,000, while Alexe and Andrew walked away with $125,000, according to BuddyTV.
Spencer’s heartfelt proposal to Jess was the highlight of the evening. “Every room that you walk into is instantly brighter,” he said before getting down on one knee. Jess’s acceptance marked a triumphant conclusion for the couple, who plan to take their time before tying the knot. As US Weekly reported, Jess will move to Dallas in 2026 to live with Spencer, solidifying their future together.
How the Other Couples Fared
The finale wasn’t just about the winners; other couples also made headlines. Kat Izzo and Dale Moss, despite facing rumors and challenges, left Costa Rica as a couple but did not make it to the final round. They later confirmed on the “Viall Files” podcast that their relationship remains strong. Meanwhile, Andrew Spencer and Alexe Godwin celebrated their commitment as boyfriend and girlfriend, posting on Instagram, “Love you level ♾️.”
Jeremy Simon and Bailey Brown, eliminated earlier, shared a touching Instagram post reflecting on their journey. “Though we didn’t win the money, we are both walking away with something far more valuable: a love that we’ve always dreamed of,” they wrote. Similarly, Leslie Fhima and Gary Levingston exited the show as close friends, with Leslie describing Gary as one of her “best friends” during an episode of the “Bachelor Happy Hour” podcast.
Behind the Scenes: Jury Drama and Eliminations
The finale wasn’t without controversy. The “Parliament of Paradise,” a jury of former contestants, was tasked with deciding which couple would join the final round. According to ABC7, this led to tense moments, including heated debates and strategic eliminations. Kat Izzo and Dale Moss were ultimately sent home, a decision that left fans divided.
Faith Martin and Kim Buike, eliminated earlier in the season, continued their relationship offscreen, sharing an Instagram video of their harmonious bond. Other pairs, such as Parisa Shifteh and Brian Autz, also left the show on good terms, though their current status remains unclear.
The Legacy of Season 10
This season of Bachelor in Paradise proved to be a testing ground for love under pressure. By integrating monetary stakes, the show added a new layer of complexity to its premise. As The Ringer pointed out, while some fans felt the finale was anticlimactic, the overarching theme of love prevailing over money resonated strongly.
Looking ahead, fans are eager to see how the relationships formed in Costa Rica will evolve. With Jess and Spencer’s engagement and plans to relocate, Alexe and Andrew’s budding romance, and the enduring friendships among other contestants, this season leaves a lasting impact on the franchise.
Ultimately, the season 10 finale of Bachelor in Paradise captured the essence of the show: love, drama, and the promise of a happily-ever-after. As the contestants move forward, their journeys will continue to inspire fans and redefine what it means to find love in paradise.