Trump and Cruz Press Cornyn Over Blocked Nomination
President Donald Trump has publicly criticized outgoing Texas Senator John Cornyn, asserting that the senator is doing a “tremendous disservice” to the judiciary by blocking the nomination of T. Elliot Gaiser to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. The vacancy, which has persisted since 2025 following the transition of Judge Jane Boyle to senior status, has become a focal point of intense political friction. In an interview with Fox News, President Trump claimed the opposition from Cornyn was rooted in personal grievances stemming from the recent primary election cycle, specifically suggesting that “John Cornyn’s feelings were hurt” after the president endorsed his challenger, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton. Trump characterized Gaiser—a senior Department of Justice lawyer, former clerk to Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, and the current head of the Office of Legal Counsel—as an “outstanding” and “fantastic” candidate who is being unfairly sidelined.
The Institutional Conflict Over the Blue Slip
At the heart of the standoff is the Senate’s traditional “blue slip” custom, an unwritten but long-standing practice that grants home-state senators the power to effectively veto judicial nominees by withholding their formal approval. By refusing to return the blue slip for Gaiser, Senator Cornyn has effectively halted the nomination process within the Senate Judiciary Committee. Cornyn has defended his stance by citing a lack of consultation from the White House, arguing that the administration failed to engage with Texas lawmakers before putting forward a nominee with limited ties to the state. In a statement posted to X, Cornyn questioned the timing of the nomination, noting that the White House waited until after the midterms to fill the seat. He further challenged the nominee’s suitability, describing Gaiser as a “non-Texan” lacking sufficient trial court experience and asserting that he had not undergone the necessary vetting for a lifetime federal appointment.
Cornyn maintains that the Senate’s constitutional duty of “advice and consent” cannot be properly fulfilled without a collaborative selection process. He has proposed an alternative candidate, Steve Fahey, a former federal prosecutor vetted by the bipartisan Federal Judicial Evaluation Committee—a body co-managed by Cornyn and Senator Ted Cruz. While Cornyn has expressed a willingness to work with the administration to fill the vacancy before his term ends in January, the lack of an existing FBI background check for his preferred alternative and the limited legislative calendar have stalled that pathway, leaving the seat’s future in doubt.
Escalation and Intra-Party Friction
The disagreement has spilled over into public hostility, most notably during a heated and profane confrontation between Senators John Cornyn and Ted Cruz on the Senate floor. Cruz, who has vocally supported the Gaiser nomination, described the encounter to Fox News, alleging that Cornyn shouted and cursed at him when approached to discuss the merits of the nominee. Cruz argued that Republicans had reached a broad consensus to prioritize the confirmation of as many judicial nominees as possible before the new Congress convenes in January. He warned that the incoming Democratic majority is likely to halt future judicial confirmations, effectively handing the Dallas-area seat to the opposition if the current vacancy remains unfilled.
The tension escalated further when Cornyn responded to reports of the altercation by dismissing Cruz as “fragile” in a post on X. Cornyn’s refusal to meet with Gaiser has been described by Cruz as a decision that effectively abandons the seat. The conflict underscores the profound fragility of the blue slip custom during high-stakes political transitions. While the Department of Justice has expressed deep disappointment, labeling the blockade as political obstruction, Cornyn insists that the Senate should not function as a “rubber stamp” for the executive branch, particularly when local consultation has been bypassed.
Stakes and Future Implications
The impasse carries significant consequences for the federal bench in Texas. As of mid-November 2026, the Senate had confirmed 57 judges during President Trump’s second term, but the momentum is now clashing with local institutional norms. For Gaiser, the path to confirmation was exceptionally fast, with his nomination sent to the Senate on November 16, 2026, following discussions that began shortly after the election. However, his ties to the 2020 election challenges and his role in writing opinions regarding the Presidential Records Act have also drawn scrutiny, adding a layer of ideological complexity to the obstruction.
As the legislative session draws to a close, the vacancy in the Northern District of Texas remains a symbol of the broader friction between the White House and senior Senate Republicans. The reliance on the blue slip, while intended to protect the interests of home-state senators, is now being scrutinized as a potential tool of gridlock that threatens to leave critical judicial seats vacant during a period of shifting Senate control. With Senator-elect James Talarico, a Democrat, set to join the Texas delegation in January, the political landscape for future judicial appointments will become even more complex, as any nominee will eventually require approval from both senators, potentially ending the era of unilateral Republican control over Texas federal judicial picks.
Reporting source: foxnews.com.

