Advertisement

Judge Allows Trump’s $15 Billion Libel Suit Against New York Times to Proceed

Popular Posts

Advertisement
Donald Trump wearing a blue suit and tie speaking at a microphone

Quick Read

  • Judge Steven Merryday denied the motion to dismiss President Trump’s $15 billion libel lawsuit.
  • The case involves allegations of tax fraud and money laundering tied to the book 'Lucky Loser'.
  • The lawsuit proceeds to discovery against the New York Times, three reporters, and Penguin Random House.
  • Claims related to Trump's academic records and TV production history were dismissed by the court.

Court Ruling Advances Libel Claims

A federal judge has ruled that President Trump’s $15 billion libel lawsuit against the New York Times, three of its reporters, and publisher Penguin Random House may proceed to the discovery phase. In a decision issued on November 19, 2026, Judge Steven Merryday denied a motion to dismiss the case, determining that the plaintiff presented a plausible claim that the defendants acted with reckless disregard for the truth when characterizing his business dealings as tax fraud and money laundering.

Advertisement

The litigation centers on the book Lucky Loser, which was published by Penguin Random House and served as the basis for two New York Times articles in 2024. The lawsuit alleges that the book falsely accused Trump and his father, Fred Trump, of participating in fraudulent tax evasion schemes. Specifically, the complaint challenges assertions that the elder Trump provided funds to his son through disguised gifts labeled as loans to avoid estate and gift taxes. According to Variety, Trump’s legal team argued that these statements were defamatory because neither he nor his father had ever been charged with or convicted of tax-related crimes. The book explicitly alleged that Trump obtained the equivalent of $400 million from his father, with much of the capital allegedly funneled through schemes designed to circumvent federal gift and estate tax obligations.

Judicial Scrutiny of Reporting Standards

Judge Merryday’s ruling emphasized a distinction between speculative expert opinion and statements presented as verified facts. While the book quoted tax experts describing Trump’s financial conduct as “highly suspicious” or suggesting it “smells like a crime,” the court found that these descriptions did not constitute a definitive factual claim of fraud. The judge noted that a clear-cut judgment would require an explicit opinion from a qualified source following a thorough investigation. “They know that they don’t know, but they are undeterred,” the judge wrote in his assessment of the reporting, suggesting that the authors may have exceeded the bounds of protected commentary by presenting allegations as established truth.

While the court allowed the tax fraud and Mafia-related money laundering allegations to move forward, it dismissed other portions of the lawsuit. Claims concerning the President’s academic records and his professional history with television producer Mark Burnett were rejected by the court. This decision follows an earlier dismissal of a more voluminous version of the suit last year; the current, more concise filing has now cleared the threshold for the discovery process and future motions for summary judgment. By allowing the case to proceed, the court has set the stage for a high-stakes legal battle that will require the defendants to defend their editorial processes and the factual basis for their reporting on the President’s long-standing business history. The case remains a significant legal hurdle for the media organization and its contributors, as the discovery phase will likely involve the production of internal communications and research materials used during the development of the 2024 articles.

LATEST NEWS

Advertisement