Old Trafford leadership is weighing up the club’s trajectory after a difficult start to the campaign that has intensified scrutiny on the coaching staff. While Carrick earned the permanent head coach role following steady work last season, recent results have triggered speculation over potential managerial targets, with Hürzeler, Antonio Conte, and Eddie Howe all linked to the post.
The Cost of Leadership Changes
According to financial breakdowns cited by Football Insider, securing Hürzeler from the Amex Stadium would require compensation between £10 million and £15 million. Brighton tied the young manager to a contract running until 2029 back in May, and club insiders maintain that the Seagulls are tough negotiators who intend to keep their coach.
Simultaneously, parting ways with Carrick is projected to cost between £7.2 million and £8.8 million, calculated using his current terms and the payout precedent set when Ruben Amorim left the club. Combined, the operational expense of a dugout overhaul would comfortably clear the £17 million threshold.
Performance Pressures and Internal Stance
Pressure has mounted following a sequence of unconvincing displays, culminating in a 3–2 League Cup defeat to Brighton on September 16, where United squandered a two-goal lead at home for the first time in 50 years. Pundit Gary Neville highlighted player performance concerns following a subsequent draw against Fulham, calling the team’s lack of effort a ‘genuine disgrace’.
Despite the noise, TEAMtalk reported that INEOS chiefs and senior club executives continue to back Carrick, retaining full trust in his ability to stabilize the squad. Sources indicate that no formal contact has been made with alternative managers.
Offering a contrasting perspective, pundit Jamie Carragher suggested on Sky Sports that Carrick is currently steadying the ship rather than acting as a long-term solution, though he warned against making hasty alterations during the early autumn international break.
Next Steps for INEOS
Sir Jim Ratcliffe and the INEOS leadership remain focused on financial sustainability and cutting operational losses, making an immediate dismissal unlikely unless United slide dangerously far behind in the race for Champions League qualification. The club prepares for its upcoming domestic fixtures under Carrick’s continued supervision.

