Hawthorn’s aggressive list management strategy has placed the future of young forward Calsher Dear under intense scrutiny. As reports circulate that Gold Coast Suns star Ben King has identified Hawthorn as his preferred destination for free agency, the Hawks are navigating a complex period of roster construction that threatens to squeeze out emerging talent.
The Forward Line Logjam
The potential acquisition of King, a marquee key forward, would significantly alter the landscape of the Hawks’ attacking structure. Hawthorn has already moved to secure its current core, with veteran Jack Gunston and key target Mitch Lewis recently signing contract extensions within a 24-hour window. These moves underscore a commitment to immediate success, but they also create a bottleneck for younger players.
Dear, 20, has shown promise since being selected by Hawthorn with pick No. 56 in the 2023 draft, and he signed an extension through 2026 late last year. Despite his development, the presence of established stars and the potential arrival of a high-profile recruit like King leaves Dear fighting for a senior spot in an increasingly crowded forward rotation.
Coach Mitchell’s Development Plan
Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell has remained characteristically measured regarding the speculation. When asked about the potential impact of King’s arrival on his forward line, Mitchell deflected, noting that team selection will be determined by performance in six months’ time. He emphasized that the club’s current focus remains on the upcoming finals campaign and maximizing the output of players already within the club’s walls.
Addressing Dear’s specific situation, Mitchell praised the youngster’s resilience. “He’s 20 years old as a key forward, I’m really pleased with his progress,” Mitchell said. “He jumped out of the blocks as an 18-year-old, then he’s had some injury and hasn’t done a full pre-season. His form on the weekend was a big step in the right direction.”
External Pressure and Strategic Risks
The speculation has drawn external commentary, with some analysts suggesting that Dear might need to look elsewhere to secure regular senior football. While Hawthorn values his development, the reality of a “win-now” list strategy often necessitates difficult decisions regarding younger players who may be ready for senior exposure but blocked by elite-level recruits.
For Gold Coast, the situation is one of transition management. Coach Damien Hardwick has confirmed that while the club hopes to retain King, they have “things in place” should he choose to exercise his free agency rights. Hardwick pointed to the successful recruitment of players like Christian Petracca and Daniel Rioli as evidence that the Suns remain a destination club capable of replacing departing stars.

