Trade Negotiations Narrow for Hawthorn Forward
Hawthorn forward Calsher Dear is actively exploring his future as the AFL trade period approaches, having officially narrowed his list of potential destinations to three clubs: Melbourne, Geelong, and Collingwood, according to reports from SEN. Carlton, previously linked to the 21-year-old, has reportedly exited the race to prioritize their pursuit of Joel Amartey.
Dear remains out of contract at the end of the current season. While his parent club, Hawthorn, has tabled a two-year extension offer, the forward is seeking greater certainty regarding his role and playing time. Melbourne is currently viewed as the frontrunner in the negotiations, having reportedly offered a four-year deal, providing significantly more long-term security than the Hawks’ proposal.
The Competitive Landscape at Hawthorn
The decision for Dear comes amid a crowded forward line at Hawthorn. The young forward, who enjoyed a breakout 2024 season with 25 goals from 17 matches, has found himself behind established veterans and key targets in coach Sam Mitchell’s rotation. With Jack Gunston, the newly re-signed Mitch Lewis, and Mabior Chol currently occupying the primary forward roles, Dear’s path to consistent senior selection has become increasingly difficult, as noted by Zero Hanger.
The situation at Waverley Park is set to become even more competitive, with Hawthorn planning to add Gold Coast Suns spearhead Ben King through free agency. This strategic shift in the Hawks’ list management has effectively signaled to Dear that his future opportunities may be limited if he remains with the club.
The Road Ahead
As the trade period nears, Dear is weighing the security of Melbourne’s four-year offer against the potential fit at Geelong or Collingwood. Collingwood, in particular, has been aggressive in the trade market, recently meeting with Dear to discuss his potential role at the club. The Magpies are already positioned as major players this offseason, having secured interest from other high-profile targets including Jesse Hogan and Lachie Neale.
For Hawthorn, the challenge lies in balancing their desire to retain young talent with the reality of an evolving forward line. Whether Dear chooses to commit to the Demons’ long-term vision or seeks a new challenge at one of his other preferred Victorian clubs remains the critical question as the trade bell approaches.