A Public Condemnation
NHL Hall-of-Fame legend Mark Messier has publicly criticized the Edmonton Oilers for their recent decision to appoint Mike Babcock as head coach, describing himself as “horrified” by the move. Speaking during an ESPN media call on September 23, 2026, the former Oilers captain questioned not only the suitability of Babcock—who has faced multiple allegations of abusive coaching tactics throughout his career—but also the unconventional hiring process that involved active player participation.
“I am absolutely shocked they hired him,” Messier stated, according to ESPN. “I don’t understand it.” Messier’s comments add a prominent voice to a growing chorus of criticism surrounding the return of Babcock to the NHL bench, following a controversial 2023 stint with the Columbus Blue Jackets that ended in resignation before he could coach a single game.
Concerns Over ‘Separation of Powers’
Beyond Babcock’s past, Messier specifically challenged the Oilers’ decision-making structure. The team confirmed that veteran stars Connor McDavid, Leon Draisaitl, and Zach Hyman were involved in vetting the coaching candidate. Jeff Jackson, the Oilers’ CEO of hockey operations, defended this approach, stating that players of their caliber “earned the right to have a voice.”
Messier, however, argued that this shift undermines the necessary “separation of powers” required within an NHL organization. “The leadership of your team has to protect the players inside the dressing room,” Messier said, as reported by the New York Post. He warned that if players are integrated into the management-hiring process, they lose their ability to act as a buffer between the coaching staff and the rest of the roster, effectively blurring the lines of accountability.
Babcock’s Track Record and Scrutiny
Babcock’s hiring follows an NHL-led investigation into his past conduct. Despite his previous success, including a Stanley Cup win in Detroit and Olympic gold medals, his reputation has been marred by accusations of verbal abuse and inappropriate behavior. Former players such as Johan Franzen and Daniel Winnik have described his coaching style as bullying and damaging to their mental health. While the league cleared Babcock to resume coaching in June, the scrutiny remains intense. Critics, including former defenseman Mike Commodore, have expressed strong disapproval of the league’s decision to provide him with another opportunity.
The Oilers’ management now faces a critical season with the highest level of external pressure. As noted by the Edmonton Journal, the team is under unprecedented observation, and any sign of mistreatment or toxic behavior will likely trigger significant backlash from the media and the league.