Regional Performance Overview
The Leapfrog Group, a national non-profit organization focused on healthcare quality, released its Fall 2026 Hospital Safety Grades on November 18, 2026. This biannual report serves as a critical benchmark for the healthcare industry, evaluating 2,367 hospitals across the United States based on their capacity to protect patients from preventable medical errors, accidents, injuries, and infections. On Long Island, the results painted a complex picture of regional healthcare delivery: while 14 facilities achieved the highest ‘A’ rating, three hospitals were assigned ‘C’ grades, and one facility—Nassau University Medical Center (NUMC)—received a ‘D’ grade. This data, widely cited in reports such as those from Newsday, provides a granular look at institutional performance across 32 distinct safety measures.
Nationally, roughly 38% of hospitals earned an ‘A’ grade in the fall 2026 cycle. For consumers, these grades are intended to function as a foundational tool for assessing care quality. However, experts like Patricia Kelmar, senior director of healthcare campaigns for the consumer advocacy group PIRG, emphasize that these assessments should be viewed as one component of a broader decision-making process. Factors such as insurance coverage, specific physician recommendations, and the historical trend of a hospital’s performance remain vital for patients selecting a healthcare provider.
Network-Wide Trends and Institutional Shifts
The performance of major health networks on Long Island highlighted significant variance in safety outcomes. Northwell Health demonstrated a strong overall showing, securing ‘A’ grades for seven of its facilities, including Glen Cove Hospital, Huntington Hospital, and Mather Hospital in Port Jefferson. Notably, North Shore University Hospital and South Shore University Hospital achieved ‘A’ grades, moving up from their ‘B’ ratings in the spring of 2026. Peter Silver, chief quality officer for Northwell Health, attributed these improvements to focused initiatives aimed at lowering infection rates and reducing complications associated with surgery and medication administration. Conversely, the network saw Peconic Bay Medical Center in Riverhead slip from an ‘A’ to a ‘B’ grade, illustrating that maintaining top-tier status requires constant, system-wide vigilance.
Other major networks maintained consistent performance profiles. NYU Langone Health continued its streak of high-level safety performance, with NYU Langone Hospital—Long Island retaining its ‘A’ grade for the 13th consecutive reporting cycle. NYU Langone Hospital—Suffolk, which merged into the system in 2025, maintained a ‘B’ grade, with leadership noting ongoing investments in quality enhancements. Within the Catholic Health network, St. Joseph Hospital improved to an ‘A’ grade, while facilities such as St. Francis Hospital and Heart Center also secured top marks. However, the network also faced challenges, with Good Samaritan Hospital maintaining a ‘C’ grade. This divergence within large systems underscores the complexity of managing patient safety across multiple campuses, where leadership transitions, staffing levels, and resource allocation can significantly influence outcomes.
Stakes at Nassau University Medical Center
The ‘D’ grade assigned to Nassau University Medical Center (NUMC) represents a significant outlier in the regional performance landscape. NUMC serves a substantial population reliant on public insurance and has struggled with well-documented financial instability, with reports indicating debts reached $1.4 billion in 2025. This financial strain is frequently cited by analysts as a contributing factor to operational hurdles that can impact safety protocols. Hospital leadership is currently developing a financial improvement plan, scheduled for submission by December 1, 2026, which may involve considerations for replacing aging infrastructure rather than continuing costly repairs. The ‘D’ grade serves as a stark indicator of the pressure facing public safety-net hospitals.
Patricia Kelmar noted that fluctuations in safety grades often reflect organizational transitions, such as leadership turnover or staffing shortages, which can lead to breakdowns in established safety protocols. She advised that prospective patients should examine the historical performance of a facility rather than relying on a single report. “The history of the organization and the grades that they’ve had over time is a really important piece of the puzzle,” Kelmar stated. “Hospitals are run by human beings, and sometimes they’re short on staff, there’s a senior leadership change, or any number of things could cause a breakdown in their patient safety protocols.”
Consumer Guidance and Future Monitoring
Leapfrog CEO Leah Binder suggested that a low grade should prompt patients to conduct a deeper investigation into specific safety measures rather than dismissing a hospital entirely. By reviewing the granular data on all 32 metrics, patients can engage in more informed discussions with their physicians about local safety protocols. In addition to the Leapfrog data, other industry experts recommend cross-referencing findings with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services star ratings and New York State hospital profile reports to obtain a comprehensive view of institutional quality.
The integration of price and quality data is also gaining momentum as a priority for purchasers and employers. According to a recent analysis by the Purchaser Business Group on Health (PBGH), there is often little correlation between the price of care and standardized safety measures, with some high-priced institutions receiving lower safety grades. This research suggests that transparency is only effective if stakeholders can act on reliable, unconflicted data. As the healthcare landscape continues to evolve, the ability of patients to navigate these reports will remain a cornerstone of informed health decision-making. The variations seen across Long Island in the fall 2026 report serve as a reminder that safety is not a static achievement but a continuous process driven by leadership, investment, and transparent accountability.
Ultimately, the Leapfrog report for fall 2026 highlights that while many Long Island hospitals have successfully institutionalized safety protocols, others face systemic challenges that require immediate attention. For the average patient, the data underscores the necessity of proactive research. By utilizing multiple reporting platforms and consulting with medical professionals, residents can better identify the facilities that best align with their safety requirements. The call from organizations like The Leapfrog Group for greater transparency, coupled with the ongoing monitoring of hospital performance, remains essential for ensuring that patients receive high-quality care, regardless of the facility they choose.
Reporting source: newsday.com.

