Institutional Criteria and Residency Disputes
On November 18, 2026, the National Book Foundation released a formal statement addressing public scrutiny regarding the eligibility of nonfiction finalist Abdelrahman ElGendy. The controversy centers on whether the author of the memoir Huna: A Memoir of Revolution, Prison, and Becoming meets the residency requirements established by the foundation in February 2024. Under these rules, authors in the nonfiction category must hold U.S. citizenship or maintain a primary, long-term home in the United States at the start of the awards cycle, which began on December 1, 2025.
The debate intensified following an essay published in The New Yorker, in which ElGendy detailed his inability to secure a U.S. visitor visa to attend the upcoming awards ceremony in Manhattan. ElGendy revealed that he had left the United States in April 2025—fearing potential arrest by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) due to his public activism—and subsequently relocated to Europe. Critics, including legal experts, have questioned whether his departure and continued residence abroad disqualify him from the prize under the foundation’s stated criteria.
Foundation Position and Publisher Claims
The National Book Foundation maintains that ElGendy remains eligible. In their statement, administrators explained that they reviewed information provided by the author’s publisher, Hogarth, which confirmed that ElGendy is a legal, tax-paying resident who fled the country temporarily due to safety concerns. The foundation noted that this context satisfied their internal eligibility assessment, which is conducted confidentially before finalists are announced.
Despite the foundation’s stance, the lack of transparency regarding how such determinations are made has drawn criticism. While the foundation previously utilized a formal petition process for eligibility disputes, spokesperson Ale Romero clarified that this process no longer exists, leaving the methodology for these decisions opaque. Furthermore, some legal observers suggest that once a competition is underway, established rules should be applied strictly. Andrew B. Lustigman, an expert in promotional law at the firm Olshan, stated in an article published by DNYUZ that the rules should be considered “set in stone” once entries are accepted.
Context and Industry Reaction
The situation has highlighted broader tensions between rigid institutional eligibility requirements and the precarious realities faced by writers in exile. Other finalists and semifinalists in the nonfiction category have issued a joint statement supporting ElGendy, characterizing the U.S. government’s visa denial as an attempt to suppress his writing. As of mid-November 2026, ElGendy has not responded to direct inquiries regarding the controversy, with his publicist citing a demanding travel schedule. The foundation continues to stand by its inclusion of Huna among the 25 finalists for the 2026 awards.

